Mark 9 contains one of the most theologically significant exchanges about fasting in the entire New Testament — and it arrives not in a teaching context but in a failure context. The disciples have encountered a boy with an unclean spirit. The father has brought him to them specifically to be delivered. And they could not. The spirit did not leave. The disciples, who had been given authority over unclean spirits in Mark 6:7, found that the authority they had been given was insufficient for the specific situation they were facing.
Jesus arrived, cast out the spirit, and the boy was healed. And when the disciples asked Him privately why they could not drive it out, His answer was this kind can come out only by prayer and fasting.
The Significance of This Kind
The phrase this kind is the most theologically loaded part of the answer. It implies the existence of a taxonomy of spiritual resistance — that not all demonic opposition is the same, that there are categories of spiritual resistance that respond to different levels of spiritual engagement, and that the level of spiritual engagement represented by prayer alone was insufficient for the level of spiritual resistance represented by this kind.
This is not a statement about the failure of faith — Jesus does address the disciples' unbelief in verse 19, but that is a separate issue from the specific instruction about prayer and fasting. The this kind instruction is specifically about the spiritual tool required for a specific category of spiritual resistance. Some things respond to ordinary prayer. Some things require the intensified, sustained, embodied engagement of prayer combined with fasting. And the person who has not learned to fast is the person who will consistently find that their prayer is insufficient for the this kind situations they encounter.
What Fasting Adds to Prayer
The question that this kind raises is the precise question that the theology of fasting in spiritual warfare must answer: what does fasting add to prayer that prayer alone cannot provide?
The answer operates on several levels simultaneously. At the most basic level, fasting intensifies prayer by removing the time and attention that eating normally requires and redirecting them toward the prayer. A person who is fasting and praying is giving significantly more sustained attention to the prayer than a person who is praying in the ordinary pattern of a day that includes three meals and the preparation and cleanup that accompany them. The sustained attention itself changes the quality of the engagement.
At a deeper level, fasting produces in the pray-er the specific spiritual condition that the most effective intercession requires: the condition of genuine, felt dependence. The comfortable, well-fed, physically satisfied person can pray for deliverance from a position of relative personal adequacy. The fasting person cannot. The hunger is a constant reminder of the inadequacy of their own resources — and that reminder, redirected toward God rather than toward the refrigerator, produces the specific quality of desperate, dependent, whole-person prayer that the this kind situations require. The fasting intercessor is not merely asking God to act. They are embodying, in their own physical state, the desperation of the person for whom they are interceding.
At the deepest level, fasting is the specific discipline that breaks the hold of the flesh over the spirit in a way that makes the spirit's authority more fully operative. Paul's language in 1 Corinthians 9:27 is relevant here: I discipline my body and keep it under control, lest after preaching to others I myself should be disqualified. The body's appetites, when ungoverned, exercise a specific influence over the spirit's effectiveness. Fasting is the deliberate, sustained practice of governing the body's most basic appetite — and the person who has learned to govern the appetite for food has developed a capacity for spiritual authority that the person who has never denied their body anything does not possess.
The Principalities and Powers
Ephesians 6:12 tells us that our struggle is not against flesh and blood but against rulers, authorities, powers of this dark world, and spiritual forces of evil in the heavenly realms. The this kind of Mark 9 is a specific expression of these spiritual forces — the category of resistance that has established itself deeply enough, over long enough, in a person or a situation that it does not yield to the ordinary level of spiritual engagement.
Daniel's twenty-one day fast is the Old Testament illustration of the same principle. The angel who eventually arrived told Daniel that he had been dispatched on the first day Daniel began to pray and fast — but the prince of the Persian kingdom resisted him for twenty-one days. The fast was sustaining the prayer that was keeping the channel open through which the answer was being fought through the spiritual resistance. The fasting did not produce the answer. It sustained the engagement that held the door open until the answer arrived.
The church that does not fast is the church that is attempting to engage in spiritual warfare without one of the weapons that the warfare requires. Not because fasting is magical. But because the this kind situations — the long-standing bondages, the generational patterns, the spiritual resistance that has established itself in a family or a community over years — require the level of spiritual engagement that only the combination of sustained prayer and sustained fasting produces.
Fasting as Spiritual Authority
The deepest connection between fasting and spiritual warfare is the connection between self-denial and spiritual authority. Jesus's authority over the demonic was exercised from a place of complete self-denial — the One who had given up the glories of heaven, who had emptied Himself, who had taken on the form of a servant. The disciples' inability in Mark 9 came at a time when they had been arguing about who was the greatest — the opposite posture from the self-denial that spiritual authority requires.
Fasting is the practical school of self-denial. The person who fasts regularly is the person who is practising, in the most basic and most physical area of their life, the posture of self-denial that spiritual authority requires. And the cumulative effect of that practice — over months and years of the fasting life — is a depth of self-denial and dependence on God that produces the kind of spiritual authority that makes the this kind situations yield.
This kind comes out only by prayer and fasting. The school of fasting is the school of the this kind.